Abel to Yzerman
Next entry: Uncle Mike Stays In The Family
Previous entry: Hasek
Drew Sharp Responds
by IwoCPO on 06/10/08 at 08:10 PM ET
Comments (53)
Two posts today blasting Drew Sharp for his dimwitted idea that the Wings should retire Dominik Hasek’s number. I emailed him, offered him the chance to respond to the questions posted here, and he has. As I told him I would, I’m posting his response in its entirety.
Your comments, as always, are more than welcome.
------------
Bill—With all due discretion, I really don’t care what fans or bloggers think. Fans have an emotional connection to a team. I don’t. That’s why I can look at a situation more objectively.
If you disagree with an argument raised, that’s great. I don’t want fans agreeing with everything I write because that doesn’t mean that my argument was right. It only means that the argument raised was popular and, quite honestly, that’s a cop out for a columnist entrusted with stirring debate and discussion. If the objective is just being liked then you shouldn’t be a columnist.
Hell, the easiest thing in the world is telling people strictly what they want to hear.
There’s no trick to that.
But the central problem in this country right now is that the art of argumentative thrust and parry is lost because too many automatically designate a point of view as “stupid,” “dumb” or “offensive” without further discussion. Nobody can just respectfully disagree anymore. It has to be insulting and demeaning.
Again, that’s why I don’t care about what fans think.
As far as retiring numbers are concerned, you can’t base a standard today on what was the case 30 years ago. Star players staying an entire 15-year career in one city is the ultimate rarity. Using your standard for retiring numbers, Lidstrom will the be the last number retired because he’ll be the last 15-year guy playing a great career with one team that we’ll see in this city because of free agency.
That’s cheapening greatness because it isn’t consistent with an ideal that was true in the 50’s and 60’s.
The Rangers retired Messier’s No. 11 after he already had a Hall of Fame career in Edmonton, solely based on the 1994 championship because that run revolved around him same as the Wings 2002 run revolved primarily around Hasek.
If you disagree with it, cool. Give me a counter argument instead of merely saying that I shouldn’t write about hockey because I don’t know what I’m talking about.
That’s just your opinion.
And since you’re a fan, it doesn’t really bother me.
Drew Sharp
-----
My response was brief.
Drew--thanks for the replies. I’ll post them, as I said I would, in their entirety. Your first sentence, if it matters, confirms everything I wrote earlier today.
Bill
Filed in: | Abel to Yzerman | Permalink
Comments
« Previous 1 2
The Drew nonsense aside, here’s how I feel about Hasek’s number being retired:
The NHL has been around for 90 years, and it’s going to be around for another 90 years, and more. It may change, but it’ll still be there. If we keep retiring numbers for everyone who did well on the team, we’re going to run out of numbers. It’ll cheapen the honor of having your number retired. That’s why we should be very selective about whose numbers we retire.
Lidstrom, without a doubt. That’s who’s getting his number retired.
Posted by Jonas on 06/14/08 at 08:53 AM ET
Jonas, in those 90 years, the tradition rich Wings have seven numbers retired, plus 99 and 16.
I’ve advocated here for the Wings retiring the numbers of their HoF all-time greats, several of them integral to the 50s dynasty with their names on multiple Cups, all of whose “greatness” was achieved primarily as Red Wings (as opposed to Hasek, who should have his number retired by the Sabres), most of whom Hockey News saw fit to place on their 100 greatest list several years ago. It doesn’t cheapen the honor to salute the guys that made our history.
So, Red Kelly, Black Jack Stewart, Marcel Pronovost, and Norm Ullman, plus in the future Lidstrom, probably Shanahan and Federov, and probably Zetterberg and Datsyuk.
That leaves 82 double-digit numbers and very little danger of running out for at least several more centuries.
Posted by BobS. on 06/14/08 at 09:14 AM ET
« Previous 1 2
Add a Comment
Please limit embedded image or media size to 575 pixels wide.
Add your own avatar by joining Kukla's Korner, or logging in and uploading one in your member control panel.
Captchas bug you? Join KK or log in and you won't have to bother.
Most Recent Blog Posts
Create Your Own Headline For The Wings/Habs Live Blog
Mellow Is The Man Who Hosts About 120 Live Blogs Per Year
“Faux”…Interesting. Do You Use “Faux”?
Detroit Media: Zero Outrage. Fedorov? Plenty
Well Gary? Your League Is A Joke
Gambling In Havana? Hiding In Honduras? Dad? Get Me To A Live Blog…STAT
About Abel to Yzerman
Welcome to Abel to Yzerman, a Red Wing blog since 1977. No other site on the internet has better-researched, fact-laden and better prepared discussions than A2Y. Re-phrase: we do little research, find facts and stats highly overrated and claim little to no preparation. There are 19 readers of A2Y. No more, no less. All of them, except maybe one, are juvenile in nature. Reminding them of that in the comment section will only encourage them to prove that. Your suggestions and critiques are welcome:
A2Y Stuff
-----------------------------
Wanna Feel Smart?
Does confusion make you sad? When you read words like "enigma" and phrases like "Thanks Gary. Ass", do you wonder why mean people speak in languages you don't understand? Fret no longer friend! The A2Y Glossary will bring you great joy and enlightenment.
-----------------------------
How Others View The A2Y 19
"Hell, I guarantee the content co-opters at Abel to Yzerman were about to link this article under the heading “Bitter Blues Fans” again right up until they just read that last half-sentance. Thanks but no thanks, you Kukla hangers-on."
--St. Louis Game Time
"I realize it’s the slow summer season, but can this guy tone down the tough-guy histrionics? His posts are fatiguing on an otherwise excellent site."
--A2Y Fan, Eternal_Fields
"I constantly marvel at how Bill (IwoCPO) and his disciples at Abel To Yzerman can be so pompous and full of themselves throughout every regular season, but come playoff time they collapse into wavering puddles of stress and nervousness as they anxiously await the impending and unavoidable collapse of the Red Wings in the post-season."
--Mile High Hockey
"I hate them because they are better than us. Of all the frigging teams…"
--In The Cheap Seats
"It's just a shame that the most classless, uneducated, lowbrow fanbase in the league gets this sweep. Red Wing fans don't deserve their team."
--Thhom
"I really don’t care what fans or bloggers think."
--Drew Sharp
"Why is it you Detroit fans are still so classless when you have such a classy hockey team, with such a professional GM and gentlemen players? I understand that the author of this blog is a manner-less cad, but the rest of you should be better."
--A2Y Fan, Jeff Beaumont
"Have you ever *read* A2Y? Its the most opinionated, juvenile stuff i've read."
--Paul Nicholson
"I actually like the Detroit team and have a sh&% load of respect for them, but their fans are the biggest douches next to Canadians."
--KStewy, PensBlog Commenter
"Just when it looks like we have bottomed out, the 19 hit a new low."
-A2Y legend, Hockeytown Todd
"And for the record, I don't hate the Red Wings, I hate their fans."
--Douche Bag at Puck Daddy who isn't Wyshynski
"You’re nothing but a douchebag ****, c3po. Go f**k yourself, and learn something about hockey in the process. Nothing ruins my day more than seeing your byline on the kk page."
--Hector, A2Y fan, statesman, Pittsburgh Chapter of Jonas Brothers Fan Club President
"I can just imagine the kindergarten teacher’s reaction when the tyke blurts out 'Mommy says Gary Bettman is a f*cking f*ckface! He wants to give ‘Rosby the bad touch.' ”
--Bella, of the 19
"A2Y is what other blog sites aspire to be when they fail to grow up: intelligent immaturity for the juvenile genius set”
--Captain Dennis Polonich, of the 19
Head to Hockeytown
Blogs the Chief Likes
When did sports writers like Drew Sharp get the idea that they have a duty to some higher cause than the fans? Where did this come from? Drew - you don’t have a job without the fans. That’s where the buck stops. Hockey exists because fans pay for it. Anyone who makes a living writing about hockey is having his or her salary ultimately paid for by the fans - the fans whose opinions you don’t care about. This isn’t politics. This is just a game that holds only as much value as the fans put into it. If you don’t care what the fans think, then get out of the business. Give your job to someone who cares.
Retiring a number is the highest honor a team’s fans can bestow on a player. You may have forgotten this, Drew, but that’s what it is - the fans. It’s a sign of respect and love from the fans, who’ve paid these players’ salaries for years. To even suggest that the fans’ opinion has nothing to do with whether a number should be retired is completely asinine. The fans’ opinion is the ONLY thing that matters in the conversation.
Screw the fans, right? They’re only peons toiling in the fields while sports writers and other noblemen go about their business. After all, you were born a sports writer, and they were born fans. It’s your divine right to carry out your duty as a sports writer.
Posted by Jonas on 06/14/08 at 08:47 AM ET