Abel to Yzerman
Next entry: See? It's Not Just Wing Fans
Previous entry: Shutting Down AO
Comparing Bourque and Lidstrom
by IwoCPO on 12/17/07 at 07:28 AM ET
Comments (5)
There are more than a few blogs with content so superior to ours that I get embarrassed and sad when I read them. So generally, I just avoid them altogether. Greatest Hockey Legends is one. Joe Pelletier has decided to compare Nick Lidstrom and Ray Bourque and I’m sure you’ll be pleased with the result. Dive fans who believe Bourque played his entire 1.23 year career in Denver are rejoicing.
Another pretty telling stat for me is post season All Star awards. In 19 of his 22 seasons Bourque was either on the first or second team, including in each of his first 15 NHL seasons. Lidstrom has “only” been honoured 8 times in 15 complete seasons, with more sure to follow. But it took him 7 years before his first all star nod.
It is the only statistical anomaly between these two great defenders. A case could even be made to suggest Bourque faced stiffer competition for All Star honours. As such, I conclude Ray Bourque’s legacy ranks him ahead of the still growing legacy of Niklas Lidstrom. But only for the time being.
Filed in: | Abel to Yzerman | Permalink
Comments
If he were to somehow challenge Bobby Orr’s 8 titles or Doug Harvey’s 7, then I think I’d be ready to give Lidstrom the nod over Bourque.
At least he is willing to leave room for future consideration. Lidstrom will certainly have the Norris this year and I have money on him for the next year as well. More importantly, he has won (at least) 4 Cups. Yes, 4. f.o.u.r
I didn’t get a regular chance to see Bourque play during his prime, and I certainly had no mind to compare his style. And I reject all wishy-washy arguments that say they were the greatest of their eras, whose dominance cannot be either compared or sullied by leaky ink pens. That’s just garbage.
So, with my limited viewing experience and subjective sepulcher in hand, I anoint Andreas Lilja the greatest defenseman ever.
Posted by srt on 12/17/07 at 01:30 PM ET
srt, I have to correct you. I anoint Andreas Lilja the greatest defenseman ever (that wears stupid ear guards on his helmet).
Posted by Nathan on 12/17/07 at 01:37 PM ET
pffffft! Different eras and style of play. My vote says Lidstrom, and hey, he’s got a few years left playing at The Joe.
Posted by cowboycoffee from San Francisco on 12/17/07 at 10:14 PM ET
Add a Comment
Please limit embedded image or media size to 575 pixels wide.
Add your own avatar by joining Kukla's Korner, or logging in and uploading one in your member control panel.
Captchas bug you? Join KK or log in and you won't have to bother.
Most Recent Blog Posts
Create Your Own Headline For The Wings/Habs Live Blog
Mellow Is The Man Who Hosts About 120 Live Blogs Per Year
“Faux”…Interesting. Do You Use “Faux”?
Detroit Media: Zero Outrage. Fedorov? Plenty
Well Gary? Your League Is A Joke
Gambling In Havana? Hiding In Honduras? Dad? Get Me To A Live Blog…STAT
About Abel to Yzerman
Welcome to Abel to Yzerman, a Red Wing blog since 1977. No other site on the internet has better-researched, fact-laden and better prepared discussions than A2Y. Re-phrase: we do little research, find facts and stats highly overrated and claim little to no preparation. There are 19 readers of A2Y. No more, no less. All of them, except maybe one, are juvenile in nature. Reminding them of that in the comment section will only encourage them to prove that. Your suggestions and critiques are welcome:
A2Y Stuff
-----------------------------
Wanna Feel Smart?
Does confusion make you sad? When you read words like "enigma" and phrases like "Thanks Gary. Ass", do you wonder why mean people speak in languages you don't understand? Fret no longer friend! The A2Y Glossary will bring you great joy and enlightenment.
-----------------------------
How Others View The A2Y 19
"Hell, I guarantee the content co-opters at Abel to Yzerman were about to link this article under the heading “Bitter Blues Fans” again right up until they just read that last half-sentance. Thanks but no thanks, you Kukla hangers-on."
--St. Louis Game Time
"I realize it’s the slow summer season, but can this guy tone down the tough-guy histrionics? His posts are fatiguing on an otherwise excellent site."
--A2Y Fan, Eternal_Fields
"I constantly marvel at how Bill (IwoCPO) and his disciples at Abel To Yzerman can be so pompous and full of themselves throughout every regular season, but come playoff time they collapse into wavering puddles of stress and nervousness as they anxiously await the impending and unavoidable collapse of the Red Wings in the post-season."
--Mile High Hockey
"I hate them because they are better than us. Of all the frigging teams…"
--In The Cheap Seats
"It's just a shame that the most classless, uneducated, lowbrow fanbase in the league gets this sweep. Red Wing fans don't deserve their team."
--Thhom
"I really don’t care what fans or bloggers think."
--Drew Sharp
"Why is it you Detroit fans are still so classless when you have such a classy hockey team, with such a professional GM and gentlemen players? I understand that the author of this blog is a manner-less cad, but the rest of you should be better."
--A2Y Fan, Jeff Beaumont
"Have you ever *read* A2Y? Its the most opinionated, juvenile stuff i've read."
--Paul Nicholson
"I actually like the Detroit team and have a sh&% load of respect for them, but their fans are the biggest douches next to Canadians."
--KStewy, PensBlog Commenter
"Just when it looks like we have bottomed out, the 19 hit a new low."
-A2Y legend, Hockeytown Todd
"And for the record, I don't hate the Red Wings, I hate their fans."
--Douche Bag at Puck Daddy who isn't Wyshynski
"You’re nothing but a douchebag ****, c3po. Go f**k yourself, and learn something about hockey in the process. Nothing ruins my day more than seeing your byline on the kk page."
--Hector, A2Y fan, statesman, Pittsburgh Chapter of Jonas Brothers Fan Club President
"I can just imagine the kindergarten teacher’s reaction when the tyke blurts out 'Mommy says Gary Bettman is a f*cking f*ckface! He wants to give ‘Rosby the bad touch.' ”
--Bella, of the 19
"A2Y is what other blog sites aspire to be when they fail to grow up: intelligent immaturity for the juvenile genius set”
--Captain Dennis Polonich, of the 19
Head to Hockeytown
Blogs the Chief Likes
Disagree. All Star “awards” mean nothing. Also, level of competition is misleading. I think it’s a wash. The disparity in numbers is obviously due to the differences in the eras in which they played. Lidstrom was a playoff MVP and won 3 Cups in the prime of his career. Bourque was a better skater, better hitter, and more dynamic offensively, but Lidstrom is better positionally (thought Bourque was excellent, Lidstrom is just the best ever in that respect) and makes a better first pass (which is critical in the trap era he’s played in). I see the similarities between the two players, but the differences is where you really have to hash it out. I think they are just about equal.
Posted by Nathan on 12/17/07 at 09:09 AM ET